By Catherine Beideman Heitzenrater and Nathan Yeary
The United States District Court for the Southern District of New York recently addressed a transferee’s attempt to use corporate veil-piercing to defend against an avoidance action by a Chapter 7 trustee. The transferee-defendant argued that its potential liability for a challenged payment from the debtor could be offset by the value that it had provided to the debtor’s nondebtor affiliate. The Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed the trustee’s action and agreed with the transferee-defendant that a nondebtor special purpose vehicle formed to acquire and hold real estate for the debtor was the debtor’s alter ego. The District Court reversed on appeal and concluded that the transferee did not have a reasonable equivalent value defense based on consideration provided to the special purpose vehicle, nondebtor affiliate of the debtor in exchange for a downpayment from the debtor.