EEOC Rescinds Its Long-Standing Criminal History Guidance In 2-1 Vote

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Karla V. Mardueño, and Christian J. Palacios

Duane Morris Takeaways:  On October 28, 2026, the Commissioners of the EEOC voted 2-1 to rescind its Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act (the “Guidance”), a document that has shaped how employers screen job applicants with criminal records for over a decade. The rescission, which the Commission announced on October 29, 2026, is effective immediately, and the Guidance has already been removed from the agency’s website.

The rescission is significant because it marks the latest step in the Commission’s retreat from disparate impact enforcement. Despite this rescission, Title VII’s disparate impact provisions remain on the books, and private plaintiffs remain free to bring such claims.

Background

On April 25, 2012, the Commission published the Guidance, which explained how an employer’s use of arrest and conviction records could violate Title VII under two theories. See U.S. Equal Emp. Opportunity Comm’n, Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act (Apr. 25, 2012). Under a “disparate treatment theory,” an employer violates Title VII by treating applicants with comparable criminal records differently on the basis of race or national origin. Under a “disparate impact theory,” a facially neutral criminal history policy may still violate Title VII if it disproportionately excludes applicants of a particular race or national origin and is not “job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity.” See 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(k)(1)(A)(i). The Guidance was premised, in large part, on concerns that broad criminal record exclusions could disproportionately screen out Black and Hispanic applicants, given disparities in arrest and incarceration rates.

To help employers satisfy the business necessity defense, the Guidance recommended that employers develop “targeted screens” that consider at least three factors: (1) the nature and gravity of the offense or conduct; (2) the time elapsed since the offense or completion of the sentence; and (3) the nature of the job held or sought. The Guidance also encouraged employers to provide applicants who are screened out with an “individualized assessment,” giving those individuals an opportunity to provide information (such as evidence of rehabilitation, references, or a successful post-conviction work history) that might change the hiring decision. The Guidance further distinguished between arrests and convictions, cautioning that an arrest, standing alone, does not establish that criminal conduct has occurred. Finally, the Guidance included numerous hypothetical scenarios illustrating lawful (and unlawful) uses of background checks, and it recommended that employers eliminate blanket policies that exclude applicants based on any criminal record.

The EEOC’s Rescission 

On October 28, 2026, the Commission voted to rescind the Guidance. The rescission passed along party lines, with Chair Andrea R. Lucas and Commissioner Brittany Bull Panuccio, both Republican appointees, voting in favor, and Commissioner Kalpana Kotagal, the Commission’s sole Democratic appointee, voting against. In its announcement, the Commission emphasized that the rescission does not restore the policy statements that the Guidance superseded, nor does it require employers to abandon any lawful practices they may have adopted in response to the Guidance. See EEOC Press Release, EEOC Votes to Rescind Enforcement Guidance on Arrest and Conviction Records (Oct. 29, 2026). Chair Lucas stated that the vote “reaffirms the agency’s commitment to enforce Title VII consistent with the Constitution and the limits Congress placed on the EEOC’s authority.” Id. She further cautioned that “[r]escinding this guidance does not give employers license to engage in unlawful discrimination – Title VII continues to prohibit discrimination based on race or national origin, including employment requirements that are proxies for intentional discrimination. The EEOC will continue to vigorously enforce these protections in accordance with the law.” Id.

Although the Commission’s announcement framed the rescission in terms of constitutional and statutory limits, without expressly naming disparate impact liability, the decision fits within the current administration’s retreat from disparate impact enforcement. In April 2025, President Trump issued an executive order titled “Restoring Equality of Opportunity and Meritocracy,” which directed federal agencies to deprioritize disparate impact enforcement and to pursue the elimination of disparate impact liability to the extent possible. See Exec. Order No. 14281, Vol. 90, Fed. Reg. 17537, Apr. 28, 2025. In June 2026, the U.S. Department of Justice’s Office of Legal Counsel (“OLC”) issued an opinion concluding that the EEOC’s interpretation of Title VII’s disparate impact provisions was unconstitutional, and that opinion expressly addressed background checks. See U.S. Dep’t of Justice OLC, Constitutionality of Disparate-Impact Liability Under Title VII (June 9, 2026).

Implications for Employers

Although the rescission marks a significant shift in the EEOC’s enforcement posture, Title VII’s disparate impact framework remains the law because it is codified in the statute itself. See 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(k). An employer facing a disparate impact challenge must still demonstrate that its criminal history screen is “job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity.” Id. As a practical matter, the EEOC will likely continue to pursue disparate treatment claims involving criminal background checks, while declining to pursue disparate impact charges and instead issuing right-to-sue letters. Private plaintiffs, however, remain free to bring both disparate treatment and disparate impact claims, and the plaintiffs’ bar may well step in to fill the enforcement vacuum left by the Commission.

Further, the rescission has no effect on the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (“FCRA”), which imposes its own procedural requirements on employers that obtain background checks from third-party consumer reporting agencies. See 15 U.S.C. §§ 1681b(b)(2)-(3), 1681m(a). Nor does it affect the growing landscape of state and local fair chance and “ban-the-box” laws, many of which impose obligations that mirror, or exceed, the recommendations in the Guidance. In short, while the rescission signals a different federal enforcement approach, the legal risks associated with criminal history screening remain alive, and employers should continue to monitor state and local laws to ensure compliance.

EEOC Lawsuit Challenging Women-Only Corporate Retreat Survives Dismissal

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Bernadette M. Coyle, and Andrew P. Quay

Duane Morris Takeaways: In EEOC v. Coca-Cola Beverages Northeast, Inc., No. 1:26-CV-115, 2026 WL 3093454 (D.N.H. Oct. 16, 2026), the Court denied the Defendant’s motion to dismiss an EEOC lawsuit alleging that a regional Coca-Cola bottler violated Title VII by excluding male employees from a company-sponsored, women-only networking event.  Applying the U.S. Supreme Court’s “some harm” standard from Muldrow v. City of St. Louis, the Court held that missed networking opportunities, the potential loss of paid time off, and the denial of perks such as a company-paid hotel stay, food, and beverages were enough to plausibly allege an adverse employment action.  The Court also rejected the employer’s argument that the event was a lawful effort to expand its pool of candidates for promotion, at least at the pleading stage.  The case comes as the Commission has made enforcing Title VII against diversity programs it deems discriminatory, including toward majority groups, a stated priority.

Case Background

The EEOC brought the lawsuit on behalf of a male production employee at Coca-Cola Beverages Northeast, Inc.’s (“Coca-Cola”) facility in Londonderry, New Hampshire.  Id. at *1.  Coca-Cola sponsored a two-day, women-only networking event, called the “Women’s Forum,” at the Mohegan Sun and Casino in Connecticut.  Id.  Coca-Cola characterized the event as a means of growing the number of qualified candidates for advancement.  Id.  The event included a social reception, team-building exercises, recreational activities, and speeches from executives about their career paths.  Id.

Only women received invitations.  According to the EEOC, the women who attended were excused from their normal work duties and paid their usual salary or wages without using paid time off, and Coca-Cola provided their hotel rooms, food, and beverages.  Id.  The EEOC alleged that male employees were not provided with any of the benefits associated with attending the event and would have attended if they had been invited.  Id.  In the EEOC’s view, shutting men out of the event meant they were treated less favorably than women in their compensation and the terms, conditions, and privileges of their employment, in violation of Title VII.  Id.

Coca-Cola moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), advancing three arguments: that the men suffered no legally cognizable injury from missing a single event; that the event was a permissible initiative to broaden the field of candidates ready for promotion; and that nothing in the complaint justified a punitive damages award.  Id. at *1-2.

The Court’s Ruling

The Court denied the motion to dismiss.

In 2024, the Supreme Court shifted the standard for Title VII discrimination claims and held that a plaintiff need only show “some harm respecting an identifiable term or condition of employment,” and that the harm need not be “significant.”  Muldrow v. City of St. Louis, 601 U.S. 346, 354-55 (2024).  The First Circuit has since read Muldrow to reach any employment event, however minor, that leaves the worker “worse off” in the terms or conditions of their employment.  Coca-Cola Beverages Northeast, Inc., 2026 WL 3093454, at *3 (citing Walsh v. HNTB Corp., 169 F.4th 330, 339 (1st Cir. 2026)).

The EEOC pointed to three categories of injury – (i) the male employees lost out on the event’s executive talks and networking; (ii) they did not receive the paid days away from work that the female employees enjoyed; and (iii) they went without the free lodging and meals that came with the trip.  Id. at *3.  Reading the complaint in the EEOC’s favor, the Court concluded that these allegations, taken together, were enough at the pleading stage to suggest that male employees may have been left worse off, even though the Court described the paid-time-off injury as only a potential one.  Id. at *4.  It also found it significant that the event was an official company function, which made it easier to link the unequal treatment to the men’s employment, particularly given the expansive way the Supreme Court has construed Title VII’s language.  Id.

Coca-Cola also argued that event was a lawful effort to encourage female employees to pursue advancement, and that attending it had no bearing on who was actually promoted.  Id.  The Court rejected this argument, explaining that the EEOC did not attack Coca-Cola’s promotion decisions.  Id. at *5.  Instead, the agency’s theory is that the particular method Coca-Cola chose, a women-only event with paid time off and perks, took away opportunities and benefits from current male employees.  Id.  

As to punitive damages, the Court noted that the complaint did not appear to allege facts supporting an award of punitive damages.  Id.  However, the Court found dismissal of the EEOC’s request for punitive damages to be improper at the motion to dismiss stage because punitive damages are a form of relief rather than a claim and are not appropriately challenged by a motion to dismiss pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6).  Id.

Implications For Employers

Employer-sponsored DEI programs are now squarely within the EEOC’s sights, and EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas has identified enforcing Title VII against diversity programs deemed discriminatory as a Commission priority. 

The decision also shows how Muldrow’s lower “some harm” threshold can make it easier for these challenges to survive the pleading stage.  Under that standard, networking access, paid time away from work, and event perks may be enough to plead an actionable injury when they are provided on the basis of sex.  A legitimate goal, such as expanding the pool of candidates for promotion, may not by itself be a defense if the means chosen ultimately deny current employees benefits because of a protected characteristic.  Employers still have arguments to press: the Court made clear that a plaintiff must show some disadvantageous consequence, and Coca-Cola may renew its arguments at summary judgment.

Employers should audit the eligibility criteria for their networking events, mentoring programs, conferences, and retreats.  They should make sure that these events are available without regard to sex or other protected characteristics.  Otherwise, an EEOC action may be on the horizon.

Webinar Replay: Year-End Review of EEOC Litigation and Strategy

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Jennifer A. Riley, and Daniel D. Spencer

Duane Morris Takeaway: Thank you to all the loyal blog readers and followers who joined us for our Year-End EEOC Litigation and Strategy Review webinar! In this 30-minute program, Duane Morris partners Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Jennifer A. Riley, and Daniel D. Spencer  analyzed the latest impact of enforcement litigation at the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, including its new National Enforcement Plan and strategic priorities established in fiscal year 2026 and the enforcement lawsuits filed over the past 12 months, and discussed how employers can navigate the EEOC’s latest enforcement initiatives and implement strategies designed to minimize the risk of drawing the agency’s scrutiny.

If you were unable to attend the webinar, it is now available on our podcast channel. Click to watch below and stay tuned for important EEOC trends and developments throughout the year.

EEOC FY 2026 Lawsuit Filings Increase Slightly And Signals A Stabilization

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Jennifer A. Riley, Daniel D. Spencer, and Alex W. Karasik

Duane Morris Takeaway: In FY 2026 (October 1, 2025 to September 30, 2026), the EEOC’s litigation enforcement activity experienced a modest uptick compared to FY 2025. By the numbers, FY 2026 concluded with 96 lawsuits filed, marking an increase from the 94 lawsuits filed in FY 2025. Although the Commission remains well below its modern enforcement peak of 217 lawsuits filed in FY 2018, the increase suggests that the EEOC has stabilized its litigation program after several years of fluctuating enforcement activity.

Overall filing totals remain comparatively low by historical standards. However, one common theme of EEOC-initiated litigation holds true: the importance of location and industry. Our analysis of the FY 2026 litigation data demonstrates that the Commission maintained an active enforcement presence while directing its resources toward targeted priorities involving disability discrimination, pregnancy-related claims, religious discrimination, and employers in several key industries. 

In sum, while the EEOC is not filing lawsuits at the pace seen during prior administrations, the Commission continues to pursue strategic enforcement litigation. Employers should continue monitoring developments closely — particularly in the geographic regions (i.e. Chicago and Philadelphia) and industries (i.e. hospitality and retail) mentioned below — and ensure compliance with all federal anti-discrimination laws and EEOC initiatives.

Lawsuit Filings Based On Month And Year

The EEOC’s fiscal year ends each year on September 30th. As in prior years, the Commission concentrated a substantial portion of its lawsuit filings near fiscal year-end. In September 2026 alone, the EEOC filed 30 lawsuits, accounting for nearly a third of all FY 2026 filings. Although September remained the busiest filing month, the concentration of year-end filings was less pronounced than in FY 2025, when 35 lawsuits were filed during the final month of the fiscal year.

Unlike FY 2025, where filing activity was relatively subdued until September, FY 2026 featured several periods of heightened activity throughout the year. The Commission filed 21 lawsuits in March 2026 and another 18 lawsuits in June 2026. After a slower July, filing activity once again accelerated through August and September, culminating in the customary year-end litigation surge.

The filing pattern suggests a more evenly distributed enforcement strategy throughout the fiscal year compared to previous years, though the EEOC’s traditional year-end filing push remained intact.

Comparing FY 2026 to prior years, the EEOC filed more lawsuits than FY 2025 (94 filings), but substantially fewer than FY 2024 (111 filings) and FY 2023 (143 filings). Although overall litigation levels remain significantly below historical highs, the increase in FY 2026 demonstrates a renewed willingness by the Commission to pursue federal court enforcement actions.

Lawsuit Filings Based On EEOC District Offices

In addition to tracking total filings, we closely monitor which of the EEOC’s 15 district offices are most actively initiating litigation. In FY 2026, Chicago and Philadelphia had 12 filings. Phoenix, Indianapolis, and St. Louis each filed 7 lawsuits. Atlanta, Birmingham, Charlotte, and Dallas had 6 filings, while Houston, Los Angeles, Miami, New York and San Francisco each recorded 5 filings. Memphis had the lowest total with 2 filings.

Like prior years, the Chicago and Philadelphia District Offices remained the primary drivers of EEOC litigation activity nationwide. Chicago increased its enforcement activity from 11 filings in FY 2025 to 12 filings in FY 2026, and Philadelphia likewise increased its activity from 11 filings to 12 filings.

Dallas doubled its activity, rising from 3 lawsuits in FY 2025 to 6 lawsuits in FY 2026. In contrast, several offices experienced modest declines, including Indianapolis, Houston, and Miami.

Overall, the data demonstrates that EEOC litigation activity remains broadly distributed throughout the country but continues to be concentrated among a handful of particularly active district offices. Employers with significant operations in Chicago, Philadelphia, and Phoenix should remain particularly attentive to EEOC charge activity and enforcement developments within those jurisdictions.

Lawsuit Filings Based On Type Of Discrimination

We also analyze the types of lawsuits the EEOC files in terms of both statutes and allegations to determine how the Commission’s enforcement priorities are evolving.

Statutory Basis

When considered by statute, Title VII again dominated the EEOC’s enforcement portfolio. In FY 2026, the EEOC filed 54 Title VII lawsuits, representing approximately 53% of all statutory filings. There were 56 Title VII lawsuits filed in FY 2025.

ADA litigation remained the second-largest category, with 36 filings compared to 35 in FY 2025. Disability discrimination continues to represent one of the Commission’s principal enforcement priorities, as the ADA filings show yet again.

One of the most notable developments in FY 2026 involved the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. The EEOC filed 12 PWFA lawsuits, doubling its FY 2025 total of 6 filings. This sharp increase confirms that pregnancy-accommodation enforcement remains a major strategic priority for the Commission.

The EEOC also filed 3 ADEA lawsuits and 4 Pregnancy Discrimination Act lawsuits. Notably, FY 2026 included the Commission’s first filings under both the Equal Pay Act and the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act in recent years, with one GINA case and one EPA cases filed.

The growth in PWFA litigation, coupled with the reappearance of EPA and GINA filings, suggests an expanding enforcement focus beyond the EEOC’s traditional Title VII and ADA docket.

Allegation Basis

The EEOC’s most frequently asserted allegations in FY 2026 remained disability discrimination, sex discrimination, and retaliation claims. Disability allegations appeared in 36 lawsuits, sex discrimination allegations appeared in 19 lawsuits, and retaliation claims were asserted in 17 lawsuits.

A significant development in FY 2026 was the substantial growth in pregnancy-related litigation. The EEOC alleged pregnancy discrimination in 16 lawsuits, making pregnancy one of the Commission’s most frequently asserted theories of discrimination.

Likewise, race discrimination claims rebounded dramatically. After only a handful of race-based lawsuits in FY 2025, the EEOC alleged race discrimination in 8 lawsuits during FY 2026. Religious discrimination litigation also increased substantially, appearing in 14 lawsuits.

Together, the increase in pregnancy, race, and religion-based claims suggests the Commission broadened its enforcement focus during FY 2026 while maintaining its traditional emphasis on disability, sex discrimination, and retaliation matters.

Lawsuit Filings Based On Industry

Analysis of FY 2026 filings by industry reveals several notable shifts in the industries most frequently targeted by EEOC enforcement actions.

Hospitality remained the most impacted industry, accounting for 21.3% of all FY 2026 filings. Retail closely followed with 22.5% of filings and experienced one of the largest increases compared to FY 2025, when it represented only 11.3% of lawsuits. The return of Retail as a primary enforcement target marks one of the most significant shifts in this year’s data.

Transportation and Logistics also experienced a substantial increase, accounting for 16.3% of FY 2026 filings compared to 10% in FY 2025. Manufacturing remained steady at 15% of all filings.

Healthcare, by contrast, experienced a meaningful decline. After representing 21.3% of EEOC filings in FY 2025, Healthcare accounted for only 14.8% of FY 2026 lawsuits. Construction also declined modestly from 8.8% to 7.5%.

Another notable change is the emergence of Education among the Commission’s most affected industries, representing 3.8% of all filings.

Overall, the distribution of lawsuits reflects a broader enforcement focus than in FY 2025. While Hospitality remained a consistent target, Retail and Transportation & Logistics experienced the largest increases in enforcement activity. Employers operating in these industries should remain particularly vigilant regarding compliance efforts and internal equal employment opportunity practices.

Looking Ahead To Fiscal Year 2027

Moving into FY 2027, the EEOC appears positioned to continue its targeted enforcement strategy while maintaining a relatively consistent level of litigation activity. Although FY 2026 produced only a modest increase in overall filings, several substantive trends emerged that may foreshadow future priorities.

Most notably, the Commission substantially increased litigation involving pregnancy-related accommodations under the PWFA and expanded its focus on race and religion-based discrimination claims. At the same time, traditional enforcement areas such as disability discrimination, sex discrimination, and retaliation remained central components of the EEOC’s litigation portfolio.

The geographic concentration of filings among the Chicago, Philadelphia, and Phoenix District Offices further demonstrates that employers must pay close attention not only to national EEOC priorities but also to regional enforcement trends.

Given the continued evolution of the Commission’s priorities, employers should expect the EEOC to remain active in pursuing strategic litigation designed to advance its enforcement objectives. Accordingly, employers should continue auditing workplace policies, training programs, accommodation practices, and discrimination complaint procedures to minimize litigation exposure and ensure compliance with federal employment laws.

Key Employer Takeaways

In several respects, FY 2026 represented both continuity and change in EEOC enforcement activity. While overall lawsuit filings increased modestly from 94 to 96 cases, enforcement remained highly targeted and concentrated in specific statutory areas, allegations, industries, and geographic regions.

Perhaps most significantly, the Commission doubled its PWFA filings and substantially increased race, religion, and pregnancy-related litigation. Disability discrimination, sex discrimination, and retaliation claims remained cornerstone enforcement priorities, while Retail and Transportation & Logistics emerged as increasingly significant enforcement targets.

Although total litigation activity remains well below pre-pandemic levels, FY 2026 suggests the EEOC has found a stable enforcement footing and continues to deploy its litigation authority strategically. As a result, employers should remain proactive in ensuring compliance with federal anti-discrimination laws and closely monitor EEOC enforcement developments throughout FY 2027.

Finally, employers can and should expect the EEOC to start paying closer attention to the use of AI in the hiring and recruiting processes. On the eve of federal government midterm elections, AI is front and center in terms of hot-button issues. The Commission’s enforcement priorities are apt to follow suit. Employers should take a proactive approach to making sure they ethically and responsibly incorporate AI into their employment practices in compliance with federal anti-discrimination laws. 

You’re Invited: Year-End Review Of EEOC Litigation And Strategy 2026

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr, Jennifer A. Riley, and Daniel D. Spencer

Mark your calendars for our bi-annual program analyzing the latest EEOC developments: Wednesday, October 14, 2026 from 11:00 a.m. to 11:30 a.m. Central. Reserve your virtual seat for the program here.

Join Duane Morris partners Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Jennifer A. Riley and Daniel D. Spencer for a live panel discussion analyzing the latest impact of enforcement litigation at the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, including its new National Enforcement Plan and strategic priorities established in fiscal year 2026 and the enforcement lawsuits filed over the past 12 months. Our virtual program will empower corporate counsel, human resource professionals and business leaders with key insights into the EEOC’s latest enforcement initiatives and provide strategies designed to minimize the risk of drawing the agency’s scrutiny.

Presenters

Gerald Maatman

Gerald L. Maatman Jr.

Jennifer A. Riley

Daniel D. Spencer

Daniel D. Spencer

EEOC Finalizes Strategic Plan And Proposes Overhaul Of Federal Sector Complaint Process

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Bernadette M. Coyle, and Elizabeth G. Underwood

Duane Morris Takeaways: On August 26, 2026, the EEOC took two significant actions – finalizing its FY 2026-2030 Strategic Plan and voting to issue a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that would fundamentally overhaul the equal employment opportunity complaint process for federal sector employees.  Among other changes, the proposed rule would eliminate mandatory pre-complaint counseling, replace the automatic right to an administrative hearing with a targeted referral model, impose heightened pleading standards, and abolish administrative class complaints. 

Given the EEOC’s responsibility to enforce federal anti-discrimination laws, these developments are a “must read” for employers.

EEOC Finalizes FY 2026-2030 Strategic Plan

The EEOC approved its FY 2026–2030 Strategic Plan, which carries forward the core priorities outlined in the draft released in early July: strategic enforcement, intake modernization, and outreach expansion.  Key performance metrics include a target of 90% favorable resolution in enforcement lawsuits and a 2% annual reduction in intake inventory from FY 2025 baseline levels.  For a detailed analysis of the plan’s provisions, see our blog post on the topic.

Proposed Rulemaking To Overhaul The Federal Sector Complaint Process

29 C.F.R. Part 1614 governs discrimination complaints against federal agencies.  Under the current framework, an aggrieved employee or applicant must contact an EEO counselor at the agency where the individual works or applied for a job within 45 days of the alleged discriminatory action, participate in counseling or an alternative dispute resolution program, file a formal complaint if counseling or ADR is unsuccessful, await an agency investigation, and then either request a final decision from the agency as to whether discrimination occurred or request a hearing before an EEOC Administrative Judge.

The proposed rule would eliminate mandatory pre-complaint counseling and replace it with a direct-filing model.  According to the EEOC, from 2017 to 2021, federal agencies conducted an average of 35,618 counselings per year, with only 385 cases settling at the counseling stage each year.  Instead, individuals would have 60 days from the discriminatory act to file a complaint directly with the federal agency at issue.  The agency would then have to investigate and issue a prompt final decision.

Another significant change is the replacement of the current automatic right to an EEOC administrative hearing with a “targeted referral model.”  Under the current system, the EEOC processes an average of 7,514 hearing requests per year, yet only 4% proceed to an actual hearing, and only 1.7% result in a finding of agency liability.  Average processing time from docketing to decision is 442 days, and successful complainants wait an average of over 2.5 years for resolution.  Under the proposed rule, after the issuance of a final decision, the complainant may appeal to the EEOC, which could refer the case for Administrative Judge proceedings when a hearing or other additional proceedings are deemed necessary or efficient.  Referral grounds include genuine disputes of material fact, credibility determinations, incomplete records, and complex issues.

The proposed rule would also eliminate administrative class complaint adjudication under Part 1614.  The EEOC cited its limited resources, approximately 2,000 employees and 70 to 130 Administrative Judges responsible for a federal workforce of nearly two million individuals and characterized class complaints as a “perennial source of delay,” with some taking over a decade to resolve at the threshold certification stage alone.  The proposal preserves putative class claims for administrative exhaustion purposes, meaning that employees could still pursue class actions in federal court.  Related individual complaints may also be jointly processed.

Key Employer Takeaways

Although the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking applies only to the federal sector, it is part of a broader enforcement realignment that private sector employers should understand.  Read alongside the EEOC’s FY 2025-2029 National Enforcement Plan and FY 2026-2030 Strategic Plan, the EEOC is signaling that it intends to concentrate its resources on specific substantive priority areas, such as DEI enforcement and disparate treatment theories, rather than casting a wide net. 

Given the volatility of the EEOC’s priorities, it is more crucial than ever for employers to stay abreast of EEOC developments and comply with anti-discrimination laws.

Eighth Circuit Affirms Jury Verdict For Employer In Racial Harassment Case, Finding Insufficient Evidence Of Failure To Prevent Discrimination

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Tiffany Alberty, and Brett Bohan

Duane Morris Takeaways: On August 4, 2026, in Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Sun Chemical Corporation, No. 25-1318 (8th Cir. Aug. 4, 2026), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment in favor of an employer following a jury verdict rejecting a hostile work environment claim brought by the EEOC and an intervenor employee. The Eighth Circuit held that even assuming the jury instructions failed to adequately cover the EEOC’s theory that the employer could have prevented the harassment, the evidence in the record did not support such a theory. The opinion illustrates the importance of employers taking prompt corrective action in response to workplace harassment and reinforces the principle that an employer cannot be held liable for failing to prevent harassment when it lacked actual or constructive knowledge of ongoing discriminatory conduct.

Case Background

Bryan Banks and Ricardo Nevarez were both technicians at Sun Chemical Corporation, a manufacturer of inks, colorants, and coatings. Id. at 1. Their relationship deteriorated over time, culminating in a confrontation in which Nevarez punched a locker while standing near Banks and screamed that Banks was a “f***ing [N-word]” three times. Id. Banks reported the incident to a manager. Id. Sun Chemical suspended Nevarez for five days without pay and warned him that future incidents would lead to further discipline, up to and including termination. Id. at 1-2. Banks received a written warning for his profanity during the exchange. Id. at 2.

Banks subsequently filed a charge of race discrimination with the EEOC. Id. After conciliation efforts failed, the EEOC sued Sun Chemical in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri, alleging violations of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Id. Banks intervened. Id. Together, the EEOC and Banks argued that Sun Chemical’s response to Nevarez using the N-word was insufficient.

The Plaintiffs’ hostile work environment claim proceeded to a jury trial. Id. at 3. The jury returned a verdict in favor of Sun Chemical, concluding that the company did not discriminate against Banks. Id.

The Eighth Circuit’s Opinion

On appeal, the EEOC argued the jury received flawed jury instructions that did not cover its theory that Sun Chemical could have prevented the harassment. Id. The instructions indicated that plaintiff needed to prove that the company “knew or should have known of the harassing conduct” and “failed to take prompt and appropriate corrective action to end the harassment.” Id. The EEOC contended that the instructions addressed only whether Sun Chemical adequately responded to the harassment rather than whether the company had failed to prevent the harassment. Id. at 3-4.

The Eighth Circuit declined to decide whether the instructions adequately reflected the EEOC’s failure-to-prevent-harassment theory, holding instead that the evidence in the record did not support such a theory. Id. at 4. It explained that, even under the EEOC’s theory, Sun Chemical had to (1) have actual or constructive knowledge of “ongoing” harassment by Nevarez, and (2) decline to take “remedial action reasonably calculated to stop it.” Id.

As to the first element, the Eighth Circuit found that, at most, Sun Chemical may have known that Nevarez had used the N-word on one previous occasion toward a different Black employee. Id.  Nothing about that incident would have placed the company on notice that Nevarez was a “known serial harasser.” Id. The Eighth Circuit distinguished cases where employers knew of continued harassment from a single isolated incident, noting that “a single harassing act might not be actionable standing alone.” Id. citing Engel v. Rapid City Sch. Dist., 506 F.3d 1118, 1124 (8th Cir. 2007).

Regarding the second element, shortly after the first incident, Sun Chemical sent a written disciplinary action to Nevarez directing him to “take a step back and begin to think about what you are about to say and the consequences that may follow.” Id. Although the Eighth Circuit acknowledged the response “could have been stronger,” it concluded that the discipline “reflected Nevarez’s more than three decades of service without a history of harassment,” and the law does not require an employer “to fire a harasser in the first instance to demonstrate an adequate remedial response.” Id. at 4-5.

The Eighth Circuit also rejected the EEOC’s unsupported argument that Nevarez used the N-word in occasional workplace conversations, finding that no one reported that conduct to Sun Chemical and there was not “enough information to raise a probability of harassment in the mind of a reasonable employer.” Id. at 5. It concluded that the occasional uses of the slur were not “so severe and pervasive that management reasonably should have known of them.” Id.

Implications For Employers

The Eighth Circuit’s decision in Sun Chemical provides several important takeaways for employers. First, the decision reinforces that an employer’s duty to prevent workplace harassment is triggered only when it has actual or constructive knowledge of discriminatory conduct. A single isolated incident, without more, does not place an employer on notice that an employee is a serial harasser requiring heightened preventive measures.

The opinion also confirms that courts will consider the totality of the circumstances, including the employee’s length of service and disciplinary history, when evaluating whether an employer responded appropriately. Employers should, however, document all known incidents and any progressive discipline, making clear that further incidents will result in escalating consequences, and in turn, underscoring the importance of reporting mechanisms. The Eighth Circuit found that the EEOC could not establish constructive knowledge of unreported incidents of alleged harassment. Employers who maintain clear reporting channels and anti-harassment policies may be better positioned to defend against claims that they should have known about discriminatory conduct that was never brought to management’s attention.

Key Insights Into The EEOC’s Draft Strategic Plan For FY 2026-2030

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Jamar D. Davis, and Olga A. Romadin

Duane Morris Takeaways: On July 1, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission released a preliminary draft of its 2026-2030 Strategic Plan.  The draft sets forth the EEOC plans to prevent and address employment discrimination via improved procedures and key performance metrics, expand outreach and training activities, and improve internal processes via talent retention and use of technology that improves efficiency.  The four-year plan was published on the regulations.gov webpage and is open for comment until July 19, 2026.  Even if employers do not submit comments, they would be well-advised to review the draft and final Strategic Plan once it is announced because it provides a window into the EEOC Commissioners’ thinking for how the agency will use its resources to redress and deter workplace discrimination.   

Introduction

Every four years, the EEOC prepares a Strategic Plan that guides its anti-discrimination enforcement priorities.  The 2026-2030 Strategic Plan newly published on the regulations.gov webpage gives significant insight into specific goals and metrics that the agency will measure its performance by in the next several years.  The three goals of the draft Strategic Plan and their significance are critical information for employers to understand in navigating interpretations and compliance with EEOC regulations and guidelines.

Operational Improvements And Performance Metrics Sought By The EEOC

The 2026-2030 Strategic Plan draft signals that the EEOC will focus its operations on three key areas.  First, the EEOC aims to increase the number of favorable outcomes and to seek non-monetary relief where appropriate. For its matter outcomes, the EEOC aims to obtain at least one million dollars in monetary relief for select systematic investigations, to favorably resolve at least ninety percent of its enforcement lawsuits, and ensure its hearings, investigations, and appears meet or exceed unspecified metrics.  (Draft Strategic Plan at 14-16.)  On this point, the draft Strategic Plan explains that the EEOC will use its prosecutorial discretion to focus on prioritizing the investigation, litigation, and resolution of complex cases.  (Id.)  In addition to seeking monetary relief, the EEOC aims to also seek non-monetary relief.  The draft Plan explains the EEOC’s view that this type of relief could encompass hands-on training for employers and workers, implementing discrimination deterrence practices, and monitoring.  (Id.)

The EEOC additionally aims to “achieve[] targeted equitable relief and at least $1 million in monetary relief” at a rate of 80% of its systemic investigations where cause is found.  (Id.)  The draft Strategic Plan states that the emphasis here is on cases with broad overall impact and relief for employees impacted by systemic discriminatory patterns, practices, or policies.  (Id.)   

Further, “the EEOC will make significant progress toward enhanced monitoring of conciliation agreements,” with the goal of publishing developments of its achievements for each year.  (Id.)  The Strategic Plan explains that improved training, enhanced tracking, and streamlined reporting are crucial aspects of this point.  (Id.)

With regards to employees of the federal government, the draft Strategic Plan outlines a baseline measurement for cabinet-level agency compliance with Equal Employment Opportunities.  (Id. at 16.)  This includes improvements in processing complaints, approving affirmative action plans, and establishing compliance with the Elijah E. Cummings Federal Employee Anti-Discrimination Act of 2020 through timeliness.  (Id.)  Reasoning that the federal government is the largest employer in the country, the draft Strategic Plan notes that “reducing unlawful employment discrimination in the federal sector is an integral part of combatting employment discrimination in the nation’s workplaces,” and thus will have a great impact on private sector employers.  (Id.)

The EEOC aims to have “at least 90% of completed investigations and conciliations, hearings, and federal appeals meet or exceed criteria” implemented in the Quality Practices Plan (“QEP”) for each program.  (Id.)  Building on the EEOC’s prior Strategic Plan’s QEP, the Commission states that the quality targets for resolving cases without litigation paved a way to success when implemented rigorously.  (Id. at 17.)  Further, the EEOC will seek to assess the current status of its previous goals and update them as needed in FY 2027-2030.  (Id.)

Next, the EEOC plans to broaden its outreach and training activities to ensure that employees know their rights, and that employers are equipped with the tools necessary to preclude discrimination. (Id. at 18-20.)  The action items for this goal include use of social media engagement, the implementation of three innovative means to conduct outreach, updating training materials to be user-friendly, and tracking the effectiveness of each outreach effort. (Id. at 19, 22.)

The EEOC additionally seeks to improve its accessibility through updating its technological capabilities.   (Id. at 17.)  The priority outlined in its seventh measure highlights reducing processing time and looks to speed up the charge filing process following intake, with the ultimate goal of reducing pending cases in the long-term.  (Id.)

Finally, the EEOC will strive to improve its overall operations via three distinct areas of focus, which include (1) personnel, (2) services, and (3) financial efficiency.  The EEOC would like to improve its operations with regards to its employees by maintaining staffing levels at or greater to 95% of the FTE baseline, invest in in-person trainings, and allow for select employees to participate in leadership development programs. (Id. at 25-26.)  For its services, the EEOC will issue feedback surveys to assess areas of growth for the intake process, outreach and training, and mediation services offered, then implement process improvements to targeted areas.  (Id. at 27.)  For budget concerns, each program area will strive to meet operating constraints and meet all submission deadlines.  (Id.)

Implications For Employers

The EEOC’s FY 2026-2030 draft Strategic Plan is a document that provides insight into the direction the agency will take to improve how it functions, and where it will focus the majority of its resources.  Knowing what to expect from the Commission over the next four years places employers at an advantage when it comes to contingency planning and updating workplace discrimination policies.

No Retake Allowed: New York Federal Court Denies EEOC’s Motion For Reconsideration In Equal Pay Act Case Against School District

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., Olga A. Romadin, and Elizabeth G. Underwood

Duane Morris Takeaways: On June 18, 2026, Judge Anthony J. Brindisi of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York denied the EEOC’s motion for reconsideration of the Court’s earlier order denying cross-motions for summary judgment in EEOC v. Hunter-Tannersville Central School District, No. 1:21-CV-00352, 2026 WL 1759441 (N.D.N.Y. June 18, 2026).  The district court found that the EEOC failed to satisfy the standard for reconsideration, reasoning that the EEOC had not identified an intervening change in controlling law, new evidence, or a clear error warranting relief.

This ruling is significant for employers defending Equal Pay Act claims and reinforces the high burden parties must satisfy to obtain reconsideration, namely, that a motion for reconsideration cannot be used to relitigate old issues or present evidence that was previously available.

Case Background

On March 26, 2021, the EEOC filed this action against the Hunter-Tannersville Central School District (“District”) alleging that the District violated § 206(d)(1) of the Equal Pay Act of 1963 by paying a former District superintendent, Dr. Susan T. Vickers (“Vickers”), less than her male colleagues for substantially equal work.  Id. at *1.  In response, the District denied the allegations and raised a statutory affirmative defense, asserting that any alleged pay disparity resulted from factors other than sex under 29 U.S.C. § 206(d)(1)(iv).  Id.

After several years of discovery, the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment.  Id.  The Court denied both motions, finding that genuine disputes of material fact precluded summary judgment in favor of either party.  Id.  The EEOC then timely moved for reconsideration, which the District opposed.  Id.

The Court’s Decision

The Court ultimately denied the EEOC’s motion for reconsideration of the Court’s order denying cross-motions for summary judgment.  Id.

First, the EEOC argued that the Court had erroneously accepted certain facts as undisputed after overlooking contrary evidence, specifically a deposition exhibit that the EEOC admittedly did not submit with its prior motion papers.  Id.  However, the Court rejected this argument for two reasons.  Id.  The omitted deposition exhibit did not qualify as “new evidence” because it was readily available at the time of the earlier briefing.  Id.  Moreover, the EEOC did not show that the omitted evidence was inconsistent with any of the challenged findings.  Id. at *2.

Next, the EEOC contended that the Court misapplied Second Circuit precedent on the question of substantial equivalence.  Id.  The Court disagreed, explaining that the Second Circuit has made clear that “[w]hether two positions are ‘substantially equivalent’ for Equal Pay Act purposes is a question for the jury.”  Id. (quoting Lavin-McEleney v. Marist Coll., 239 F.3d 476, 480 (2d Cir. 2001)).  In particular, the Court determined that the EEOC did not show a clear error in the Court’s application of the law because the “expansive record” included “sufficient evidence from which a reasonable factfinder could conclude that Vickers’ comparators had different or additional job responsibilities and performance requirements.”  Id.

The EEOC also argued that the Court failed to require the District to “prove” that the pay disparities between Vickers and her comparators stemmed from gender-neutral factors.  Id. at *3.  The Court, however, determined that the EEOC’s argument misunderstood the relative burdens on a motion for summary judgment.  Id.  While the District would have needed to “prove” its affirmative defense as a matter of law to succeed on its own motion, to survive the EEOC’s motion and get to trial, “the District was only required to identify sufficient evidence from which a reasonable factfinder could conclude that ‘the pay disparity in question result[ed] from a differential based on any factor except for sex.’”  Id. (quoting Eisenhauer v. Culinary Inst. of Am., 84 F.4th 507, 522–23 (2d Cir. 2023)).  The Court found the District met that standard.  Id.

Finally, the Court rejected the EEOC’s argument that the Court failed to apply the law requiring the District to prove that longevity and negotiation were gender-neutral factors.  Id.  In rejecting the EEOC’s argument, the Court noted that the EEOC cited no controlling authority for the proposition that longevity and negotiations cannot constitute factors other than sex, identifying several courts within the Second Circuit that have found such factors to be legitimate factors other than sex.  Id.

Because the Court declined to reconsider its earlier ruling, the Court indicated that the EEOC’s contingent requests regarding the issues of willfulness, good faith, and damages were rendered moot.  Id. at *4.

Implications For Employers

The Court’s decision underscores that motions for reconsideration are subject to a demanding standard and cannot be used as a second opportunity to relitigate issues or present evidence that was available during an earlier round of briefing.

This decision also reinforces that the question of whether two job positions are “substantially equivalent” under the Equal Pay Act is a fact-intensive inquiry properly reserved for a jury, and that shared job descriptions alone do not establish substantial equivalence as a matter of law.  Id. at *2.

Lastly, the Court’s analysis confirms that longevity and salary negotiations remain viable “factors other than sex” under the Equal Pay Act in the Second Circuit.  Id. at *3.  Employers should therefore document the legitimate, gender-neutral factors underlying compensation decisions to support a potential affirmative defense in the event of an Equal Pay Act challenge.

President Trump’s New National Enforcement Program For The EEOC And What It Means For Employers

By Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., George J. Schaller, and Ryan T. Garippo

Duane Morris Takeaways:  On June 4, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (the “EEOC”) announced its National Enforcement Plan (the “NEP”) for fiscal years 2025 – 2029.  The NEP reflects the EEOC’s new priorities under President Donald Trump and formally rescinds the agency’s strategic objections during President Joseph Biden’s administration. 

Employers should take note of this development as it is clear that the NEP signals a forthcoming crackdown on: (1) employers’ diversity, equity, and inclusion (“DEI”) programs; (2) instances of “anti-American” bias; (3) efforts to limit “single-sex spaces” for transgender individuals; and (4) failures to provide religious accommodations.

The EEOC’s National Enforcement Plan

As readers of this blog will know, the EEOC looks and acts differently under President Trump than it did under President Biden.  President Biden’s strategic priorities, which we wrote about here, here, and here, largely focused on discrimination resulting from the use of artificial intelligence, preventing systemic harassment, enforcing equal pay obligations, and protecting historically marginalized groups.  President Trump’s EEOC is a lot different.

On June 4, 2026, the EEOC’s Chair Andrea Lucas (R) and Commissioner Brittany Panuccio (R) rolled out the agency’s new NEP over the objection of Commissioner Kalpana Kotagal (D).  The NEP describes the agency’s areas of strategic focus because “it is not feasible for the [EEOC] to devote the same amount of resources to each charge.”  (NEP at 2.)  Thus, “the agency must continue to be strategic about the matters it prioritizes to maximize the agency’s impact.”  (Id.)  To that end, the EEOC identified four major areas where it intends to be more proactive in its enforcement efforts, each of which is discussed more fully below.

First, the EEOC stated an explicit intention to attempt to “[r]emedy[] DEI-related race and sex discrimination.”  (Id. at 6.)  In particular, the EEOC cited the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent decisions in Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services, 605 U.S. 303 (2025), Muldrow v. City of St. Louis, Missouri, 601 U.S. 346 (2024), and Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President & Fellows of Harvard College, 600 U.S. 181 (2023) as the basis for its decision.  As a result, we expect to see continued efforts from President Trump’s administration to crackdown on DEI programs both in the workplace and in higher education.

Second, the EEOC states that it plans to prosecute claims with an intent to “protect[] American workers from anti-American national origin discrimination.”  (NEP at 6.)  This prosecutorial decision tracks with last year’s first-of-its-kind settlement against LeoPalace Resort, which we blogged about here, where a group of American workers alleged that they were subject to less favorable treatment than their Japanese colleagues.  We can also expect these enforcement actions to continue throughout the second Trump administration.

Third, the EEOC intends to ensure access for women to “single-sex spaces at work” due to the “binary nature of sex.”  (Id.)  This objective continues to signal a rollback of President Biden’s efforts to enforce protections in favor of transgender workers, and tracks with the agency’s decision last year to dismiss all lawsuits seeking to enforce such protections.  As readers will recall, we blogged about the decision to dismiss these lawsuits here because they were purportedly based on “gender ideology extremism.”  This area is one where there is the potential for a significant uptick in EEOC enforcement actions and investigations.

Fourth, the EEOC stated its continued commitment to “religious liberty rights” including the right “to receive religious accommodations and be free from religious discrimination, harassment, and related retaliation.”  (Id.)  As we explained here, however, employers can expect certain types of religious bias to be policed more heavily than others.  In accordance with President Trump’s policy platform, EEOC Chair Lucas has explicitly cited “antisemitism” as the basis for the current emphasis on religious discrimination.  This enforcement priority tracks with recent appellate court decisions, such as EEOC v. Center One, LLC, No. 22-2943, 2024 WL 379956, at *4 (3d Cir. Feb. 1, 2024), where the Third Circuit held that forcing an employer to work on Yom Kippur and Rosh Hashanah could create “’intolerable’ conditions of discrimination.”  Thus, the EEOC is signaling its intent to continue to build on precedent like Center One in the religious discrimination space.

Implications For Employers

Employers should take note of these enforcement priorities as it previews the types of cases that the EEOC intends to pursue both through investigations and litigation.  Thus, if they have not already, corporate counsel should consider whether any revisions are necessary to their organization’s DEI programs as well as to any policies concerning differential treatment provided based on national origin, sex, or religion.

Further, if an organization receives notice of an EEOC charge or subpoena – particularly one targeting a pattern, practice, or policy based on the above-mentioned objectives – it should take such allegations extremely seriously and contact experienced counsel to help them navigate the process.

© 2009- Duane Morris LLP. Duane Morris is a registered service mark of Duane Morris LLP.

The opinions expressed on this blog are those of the author and are not to be construed as legal advice.

Proudly powered by WordPress